Community Relations Council
Equity Diversity Interdependence
Promoting a Peaceful and Fair
Society based on Reconciliation
and Mutual Trust.
Consortium (Pobal/Community Relations Council) Steering Committee Meeting June 2011
30 June 2011
Theme 1.2 Acknowledging and Dealing with the Past Thursday 30th June 2011
Minutes
Meeting: Thursday 30th June 2011
Venue: CRC Offices, Belfast
Present: Tony McCusker (Chair), Brendan Mackin, Helen Johnston, Billy Gamble (temporary representation for Jackie Witherow), Stella McDermott, Martina Hanna (replacing Lisa-Jane McIlveen), Jim Deery, Clifford Kelly, Mary Cunningham, Aidan O’Reilly,
In attendance: DFP: Jonathan Ashe (representing Martin Tyrell)
SEUPB:Shaun Henry
Pobal: Denis Leamy, Paddy McGinn, Colette Nulty
Community Relations Council: Duncan Morrow, Jacqueline Irwin, Frank Murphy, Gordie Walker, Naomi Doak, Patricia McShane (Minutes)
Apologies: Martin Tyrell
Chairperson
The Chair welcomed the new committee member Martina Hanna (OFMDFM), Jonathan Ashe who was deputizing for Martin Tyrell (DFP) and Billy Gamble who will be deputizing for Jackie Witherow. All those present were invited to introduce themselves to the committee
Due to the chairperson only being available until 2.00pm it was agreed that Billy Gamble would chair the meeting after lunch.
1 Conflict of interest:
1.1. Declaration of conflict of interest for meeting
The following members completed and signed a form in relation to items under 7.1 on the agenda:
Clifford Kelly (032296), Brendan Mackin (032288 and 029025), Martina Hanna (032231), Helen Johnston (032138 and 032090), Billy Gamble (032177) and Jim Deery (32284).
It was agreed that members would absent themselves if and when any discussion took place on the assessment of the groups they have a conflict of interest with.
2 Minutes:
The minutes of the previous meeting held on Thursday 12th May 2011 were agreed.
3 Matters Arising:
3.1. Project ref no: 002853, National Museums NI:
The following update was noted:
· The application has been to the Economist and a number of queries on the Economic Appraisal have been answered. Staff are waiting on final comments from the Economist with a pre-contract check being carried out in the interim period. The final appraisal taking on board the comments will be presented to the committee for approval at the next meeting on 7th September 2011
4 Update;
4.1. Financial update on Theme 1.2 Acknowledging and Dealing with the Past
The Steering Committee was presented with an overview of the current allocations against budget as at the 23rd June 2011. It was noted that the Revised Net Commitment amount was miscalculated and the calculations need revised.
The total available budget for the Open Call is currently €27,316,405
5 Theme 1.2 Open Call Presentation and Discussion:
Members were given a short presentation on the following:
5.1. Assessment and Selection Procedure:
Stage 1
· An eligibility check and programme and priority/theme desk based assessment has been completed for all applications.
· Applications require a minimum combined score on programme and priority/theme of 65% to progress to Stage 2 of the assessment and selection procedure. Failure to score 65% would be a fail and the application proposed for rejection.
· The Stage 1 Assessments will be presented to the Theme 1.2 Steering Committee for consideration and approval.
Stage 2
- For those applications progressing to Stage 2 an efficiency and effectiveness (minimum score 26/65%) and cross cutting themes assessment (Minimum score 9-12 in each theme) will be carried out.
- Written clarifications will be sought and meetings where necessary will take place with applicants.
- Applicants will require a combined score of 65% (130) to be recommended for funding.
- For applications over £475,000/€690,000 an External Economic Appraisal is required. I The Economic Appraisal process will be completed in parallel with the Stage 2 Assessment process. A discussion took place regarding the External Economic Appraisal threshold and the reasons for lowering the level from £500,000/€750,000. It was clarified that due to some projects applying for an amount slightly under the external economic appraisal threshold a lowering of threshold was needed to incorporate these applications. It was also clarified that committee members may ask for an External Economic Appraisal to be carried out for any application which they see appropriate.
- The final assessment report incorporating the Stage 1 Assessment and external economic appraisal, if applicable, will be presented to the Theme 1.2 Steering Committee for approval/rejection
- It was noted that during the Stage 2 assessment and selection process the scores presented during Stage 1 may change as a result of the full assessment having taken place.
5.2. Peace Building and Reconciliation Overview:
- Members were informed that the Peace III Operational Programme, Deloitte Review and SEUPB Guidance Notes on Project Selection (G1/PIII) and Principles for Implementation (G19/PIII) has provided the framework and the basis for assessments of peace and reconciliation impacts and the rationale for the recommended scores.
5.3. Overview of Applications:
· 113 Applications were received.
· 9 Applications were deemed ineligible.
· 99 Applications were under consideration between the May and June Steering Committee meetings.
· 5 Applications rejected at the May Steering Committee meeting.
6 Project recommendations for consideration
6.1. Stage 1 Assessments
The Case/Development Officers were available to answer any specific enquiries from committee members.
All decisions have been recorded on the Stage 1 Decision Grid attached.
The Committee stopped for lunch at this point and Billy Gamble took over the chairperson’s role upon re-commencement of the meeting.
6.2. Request for Increase in Grant Aid – Queen Mary
A discussion took place regarding the Queen Mary University of London’s request for an increase in grant aid and it was agreed to grant an extension of time but the request for additional monies was rejected.
6.3. De-committals, transfers and extensions
· Teach Oscail (710), Wave (778), SEFF (1404), Wave (1461) and Falls Community Council (795) de-committal figures were confirmed
· All other de-committals and transfers were noted by the Steering Committee.
7 AOB
The Steering Committee commended staff for the work that has taken place so far with regards to the Open Call assessments.
8 Date of Next Meeting: 11.30am Wednesday 7th September 2011
Pobal Offices, Monaghan
| Ref | Applicant | Project Title | Amount Requested | Recommended Score | Team Recommendation | STEERING COMMITTEE DECISION | ||||||
| SCORE | ||||||||||||
| Programme Objectives | Priority & Theme Objectives | DECISION | Programme Objectives | Priority & Theme Objectives | ||||||||
| MAILOUT 1: Recommendations | ||||||||||||
| 1 | 032168 | INCORE, University of Ulster, Magee campus, Northland Road | Accounts of the Conflict | £3,459,594 total project costs. £2,802,157 requested from Peace III programme. | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: In addition to team notes the following are to be added: · Demonstration of value for money required. | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | ||
| 2 | 032164 | Healing through Remembering | Voyager | £1,365,082.75 | 39 (65%) | 39 (65%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: | Rejected Without the availability of the mentioned report due to be published in Autumn the information provided in the application is deemed as being based on supposition. Therefore the score was reduced accordingly. | 34.5 (57.5%) | 36 (60%) | ||
| 3 | 031829 | WAVE | Learning from the Past to educate our Future | £1,273,748 | 39 (65%) | 39 (65%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: In addition to team notes the following are to be added: · Confirm the capacity to deliver the proposed project. · Sustainability of the proposed project. · Examine the potential to merge both applications from WAVE under Theme 1.2, subject to clarification on procedure with the Managing Authority · Further Clarification required in terms of target groups and areas | 39 (65%) | 39 (65%) | ||
| 4 | 032130 | Junior Achievement | Our World | €749,476 | 44 (73%) | 40 (70%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 44 (73%) | 40 (70%) | ||
| 5 | 031822 | WAVE | Breaking the cycle of the troubles legacy for our future generations | £714,913.00 | 42 (70%) | 39 (65%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 42 (70%) | 39 (65%) | ||
| 6 | 032214 | Inishowen Women’s Information Network | Women Working Well Together | €667,546 | 40.5 (67.5%) | 40.5 (67.5%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 40.5 (67.5%) | 40.5 (67.5%) | ||
| 7 | 032063 | IFA | Football for All – Looking Back to Move Forward | £618,406.00 | 42 (70%) | 39 (75%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 42 (70%) | 39 (75%) | ||
| 8 | 032030 | Latton Social Services and Development | Roadways of Memories | €611,140 | 43.5 (72.5%) | 40.5 (67.5%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 43.5 (72.5%) | 40.5 (67.5%) | ||
| 9 | 032191 | Holywell Trust | Fairytales | £597,246 | 40.5 (67.5%) | 40.5 (67%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 40.5 (67.5%) | 40.5 (67%) | ||
| 10 | 029456 | Community Dialogue | Transformational Dialogues Project | £520,608 | 42 (70%) | 39 (65%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 42 (70%) | 39 (65%) | ||
| 11 | 032255 | Monaghan Education Centre | Embracing Shared Communities | €500,000 | 48 (80%) | 45 (75%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 48 (80%) | 45 (75%) | ||
| 12 | 032211 | North West Play Resource Centre | Theatre of Witness | £499,650 | 43.5 (72.5%) | 43.5 (72.5%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 43.5 (72.5%) | 43.5 (72.5%) | ||
| 13 | 032250 | Suffolk and Lenadoon Interface Group | Interface Exchange – “Delivering a Shared Future across Belfast and Beyond” | £498,702.35 | 45 (75%) | 42 (70%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 45 (75%) | 42 (70%) | ||
| 14 | 030008 | The Junction | Ethical and Shared Remembering Commemoration in a New Context | £487,740 | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | ||
| 15 | 032042 | Seaview Ents | Mes Que un Club” – towards a shared cross-community stadium | £485,520 | 42 (70%) | 39 (65%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: In addition to team notes the following are to be added: · Examine capacity of the promoter to manage and implement the project · Further clarify the community relations aspect of the proposed project · Seek confirmation of funding for the capital development in the area and which will be implemented in parallel to this proposal | 42 (70%) | 39 (65%) | ||
| 16 | 032312 | Ely centre | The BEAT project | £445,734.38 | 39 (65%) | 39 (65%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: In addition to team notes the following are to be added: · Seek clarification on the level of cross community participation and engagement within the project · Examine further the promoters ability to achieve outcomes. · Clarify further progression to reconciliation pathways outlined in the application . | 39 (65%) | 39 (65%) | ||
| 17 | 032295 | Verbal Arts Theatre | CROWS ON THE WIRE | £384,417.50 | 46.5 (77.5%) | 46.5 (77.5%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 46.5 (77.5%) | 46.5 (77.5%) | ||
| 18 | 032236 | The Terry Enright Foundation | Building the Future | £361,710 | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: In addition to team notes the following are to be added: · Clarify links to other local groups · Clarify how they work with NRA’s and CEP’s | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | ||
| 19 | 029561 | Diversity Challenges | The Green and Blue across the Thin Line | £258,600 | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | ||
| MAILOUT 2: Recommendations | ||||||||||||
| 20 | 032290 | South East Fermanagh Foundation (SEFF) | The Northern Ireland Phoenix Project | £3,699,526.00 | 42 (70%) | 40.5 (67.5%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: In addition to team notes the following are to be added: · Clarification of process to recruit high number of beneficiaries. | 42 (70%) | 40.5 (67.5%) | ||
| 21 | 032240 | Falls Community Council | Belfast Conflict Resolution Consortium (BCRC) | £1,117,920.30 | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | ||
| 22 | 032272 | Inishowen Development Partnership | Engage Youth | €748,350.00 | 48 (80%) | 45 (75%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 48 (80%) | 45 (75%) | ||
| 23 | 032271 | Community Workers Co-operative | Collective Action for Positive Peace (CAPP) Project | €731,260.91 | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | ||
| 24 | 031760 | Ionad Forbartha Gnó Teo. t/a WESTBIC | Glórtha Aduaidh (Northern Voices | €724,939.00 | 40.5 (67.5) | 42 (70%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 40.5 (67.5) | 42 (70%) | ||
| 25 | 03230 | Calipo Theatre Co | Sharp Focus – Crossing the Divide | €620,621.00 | 42 (70%) | 45 (75%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 42 (70%) | 45 (75%) | ||
| 26 | 030235 | Expac | Future Resolutions | €582,306.00 | 40.5 (67.5%) | 42 (70%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment:
In addition to team notes the following are to be added: · Relevance and appropriateness of the history content of the courses to be clarified with the promoter, in particular to ensure that a balanced view and different perspectives of history are taken account of in the courses provided · In relation to the proposed training for mental health practitioners, the promoter must clarify how they going to achieve this · The capacity of the promoter to deliver on the the E learning initiatives to be confirmed | 40.5 (67.5%) | 42 (70%) | ||
| 27 | 031500 | Manorhamilton Enterprise Forum Ltd | Communities Together | €538,772.92 | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | ||
| 28 | 032299 | Smashing Times Theatre Company | The Memory Project | €528,758.00 | 40.5 (67.5%) | 40.5 (67.5%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 40.5 (67.5%) | 40.5 (67.5%) | ||
| 29 | 032091 | Public Achievement Ltd | Beyond the Margins – Addressing the Legacy of Violence in the Lives of Young Citizens | £499,982.00 | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | ||
| 30 | 031710 | Taughmonagh Community Forum Limited | Legacy | £499,848.11 | 39 (65%) | 40.5 (67.5%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 39 (65%) | 40.5 (67.5%) | ||
| 31 | 032107 | County Monaghan VEC | Acknowledge the Past, Explore the Present and Shape the Future | €499,328.00 | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | ||
| 32 | 029489 | Relatives for Justice | Transitional Legacies | £499,328.00 | 39 (65%) | 40.5 (67.5%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: In addition to team notes the following are to be added: · Clarification is needed regarding cross community work and objectives. · Clarification on the location of the project and the venues to used for project delivery | 39 (65%) | 40.5 (67.5%) | ||
| 33 | 032238 | Youth Link: NI | Building Positive Sustainable and Integrated Communities | £498,742.00 | 49.5 (82.5%) | 46.5 (77.5%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 49.5 (82.5%) | 46.5 (77.5%) | ||
| 34 | 032167 | Tyrone Donegal Partnership | Respecting Our Memories (ROM) | £498,500.00 | 40.5 (67.5%) | 40.5 (67.5%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 40.5 (67.5%) | 40.5 (67.5%) | ||
| 35 | 029464 | Belfast Interface Project (BIP) | Enabling Our Future | £494,112.00 | 40.5 (67.5%) | 40.5 (67.5%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 40.5 (67.5%) | 40.5 (67.5%) | ||
| 36 | 032247 | N Ireland Rural Development Council (RDC) | Media Initiative for Rural Children Cross Borders | £491,178.14 | 40.5 (67.5%) | 42 (70%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 40.5 (67.5%) | 42 (70%) | ||
| 37 | 032284 | Ashton Community Trust | Exploring the Past for a Better Future | £476,301.08 | 39 (65%) | 39 (65%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: In addition to team notes the following are to be added: · Clarify ‘who am I’ and ‘Making sense of past and present’ initiatives · Clarify proposed reconciliation outcomes. · Additional information on proposed visits. · Clarification of ‘informal’ or ‘formal’ processe outlined in the application | 39 (65%) | 39 (65%) | ||
| 38 | 032288 | BURC | CAFÉ II (Citizenship and Fellowship Education) | £449,728.75 | 45 (75%) | 42 (70%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: In addition to team notes the following are to be added: · Capacity and Developmental aspects to be confirmed. · Value for Money and costs to be clarified · Consider with the promoter the opportunity to combine the two current applications under this theme, post clarification from the Managing Authority | 45 (75%) | 42 (70%) | ||
| 39 | 029025 | BURC | DISC II | £449,576.88 | 42 (70%) | 39 (65%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: In addition to team notes the following are to be added: · Management Capacity and developmental aspects to be further clarified · Value for Money and costs to be clarified Consider with the promoter the opportunity to combine the two current applications under this theme, post clarification with the Managing Authority | 42 (70%) | 39 (65%) | ||
| 40 | 031245 | Youth Initiatives | Crosslinks Legacy Project | £437,807.00 | 39 (65%) | 42 (70%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 39 (65%) | 42 (70%) | ||
| 41 | 032268 | The Nerve Centre | The Conflict Digital Archive (CDA) | £427,650.00 | 40.5 (67.5%) | 39 (65%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 40.5 (67.5%) | 39 (65%) | ||
| 42 | 029066 | North West Lifelong Learning Ltd | Silent Voices | £366,354.00 | 40.5 (67.5%) | 39 (65%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 40.5 (67.5%) | 39 (65%) | ||
| 43 | 032280 | Ulster Peoples College | Peoples History Initiative | £359,832.17 | 39 (65%) | 39 (65%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: In addition to team notes the following are to be added: · Clarification on impact of proposed project. · Clarify where the proposed course participants will be recruited from. Applicant to provide recruitment and selection strategy | 39 (65%) | 39 (65%) | ||
| 44 | 031729 | Best Cellars Music Collective | Dare to Dream | £310,640.00 | 42 (70%) | 45 (75%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 42 (70%) | 45 (75%) | ||
| 45 | 032293 | ADoPT | Removing Barriers | €181,355.00 | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 42 (70%) | 42 (70%) | ||
| 46 | 032292 | Forthspring Inter Community Group | 5 Decades | £167,405.60 | 42 (70%) | 40.5 (67.5%) | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment | 42 (70%) | 40.5 (67.5%) | ||
| MAILOUT 1: Rejections | ||||||||||||
| 47 | 032222 | Community Change | Community Immersion | £1,074,200.00 | 18 (30%) | 24 (40%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 18 (30%) | 24 (40%) | ||
| 48 | 032138 | Institute for Conflict Research | The Legacy of Peacebuilding in Northern Ireland and the Border Regions | £637,204.00 | 21 (32%) | 0 (0%) | Rejection: Project did not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 21 (32%) | 0 (0%) | ||
| 49 | 032330 | Artswell | Using Art to Heal the Heart: Exploring and Reconciling Culture on the Border | €606,538.38 | 27 (45%) | 24 (40%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 27 (45%) | 24 (40%) | ||
| 50 | 032192 | Foroige | Youth Working for Future Peace | €550,000.00 | 28.5 (47.5%) | 27 (45%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 28.5 (47.5%) | 27 (45%) | ||
| 51 | 031971 | Spirit of Enniskillen Trust | Young people leading change | £513,411.00 | 24 (40%) | 27 (45%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives. | Rejected | 24 (40%) | 27 (45%) | ||
| 52 | 032158 | Cruse Bereavement Care in Northern Ireland | Restoring Hope | £498,356.00 | 18 (30%) | 9 (15%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 18 (30%) | 9 (15%) | ||
| 53 | 032073 | Cunamh | Making Their Past Ensure our Futures | £484,039.00 | 24 (40%) | 27 (45%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 24 (40%) | 27 (45%) | ||
| 54 | 031000 | Cavan Family Resource Centre | Border Links | €474,891.74 | 31.5 (52.5%) | 30 (50%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives. | Rejected | 31.5 (52.5%) | 30 (50%) | ||
| 55 | 032152 | Ramelton | R.O.O.T.S. 2 | €431,037.00 | 33 (55%) | 31.5 (52.5%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives. | Rejected | 33 (55%) | 31.5 (52.5%) | ||
| 56 | 032189 | Tara Centre | From Polarization & Prejudice to Integration & Inclusivity: An Enlightened Journey of Trans-formation | £403,728.89 | 36 (60%) | 37.5 (62.5%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 36 (60%) | 37.5 (62.5%) | ||
| 57 | 032169 | Towards Understanding and Healing | Sustaining and Developing Storytelling and Dialogue Processes Towards Understanding and Healing | £393,957.00 | 33 (55%) | 33 (55%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Deferred: The rationale for scores presented to be further clarified Staff requested to review the assessment and scores and circulate to committee for consideration by written procedure electronically to committee members for comments. | ||||
| 58 | 032228 | South Armagh Rural Women’s Network (SARWN) | Borders and Boundaries | £378,800.00 | 36 (60%) | Nil | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 36 (60%) | Nil | ||
| 59 | 029590 | Institute for Counselling & Personal Development | Bridging the Gap | £374,322.00 | 19.5 (32.5%) | 21 (35%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 19.5 (32.5%) | 21 (35%) | ||
| 60 | 029645 | Ely Centre | ARCHIVE | £350,626.00 | 30 (50%) | 28.5 (47.5%) | Rejection: Project did not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 30 (50%) | 28.5 (47.5%) | ||
| 61 | 029136 | Survivors of Trauma | A Future Together II | £333,574.80 | 33 (55%) | 33 (55%) | Rejection: Project did not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 33 (55%) | 33 (55%) | ||
| 62 | 032264 | The MAC | Reconciliation through Arts project (RAP) | £324,461.00 | 30 (50%) | 30 (50%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 30 (50%) | 30 (50%) | ||
| 63 | 032269 | Trademark | Cultural Connections-Towards a Shared heritage | £248,500.00 | 34.5 (57.5%) | 31.5 (52.5%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 34.5 (57.5%) | 31.5 (52.5%) | ||
| 64 | 031972 | Newry & Mourne | Rumblings From The Past To Present And Future | £206,405.96 | 33 (55%) | 30 (50%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 33 (55%) | 30 (50%) | ||
| MAILOUT 2: Rejections | ||||||||||||
| 65 | 032307 | Causeway Institute for Peace building and Conflict Resolution | Remember Me | £2,782,527.00 | 27 (45%) | 33 (55%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 27 (45%) | 33 (55%) | ||
| 66 | 032090 | County Dublin Vocational Education Committee, Curriculum Development Unit (CDVEC) | Education For Reconciliation | €998,185.43 | 24 (40%) | 24 (40%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 24 (40%) | 24 (40%) | ||
| 67 | 032270 | Northern Ireland Association For Mental Health (NIAMH) | Moving Past Trauma | £776,862.00 | 19.5 (32.5%) | 36 (60%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 19.5 (32.5%) | 36 (60%) | ||
| 68 | 032223 | Rural College | Our Story Our Peace : The Experiences of Women Living in the Border Region | €615,454.00 | 36 (60%) | 37.5 (62.5%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 36 (60%) | 37.5 (62.5%) | ||
| 69 | 032332 | Causeway Institute for Peacebuilding and Resolution (CIPCR) | Victims Advocacy | £584,209.00 | 24 (40%) | 27 (45%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 24 (40%) | 27 (45%) | ||
| 70 | 032161 | Truagh Development Association | Stepping Stones Project Stage 3 | £561,500.00 | 18 (30%) | 24 (40%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 18 (30%) | 24 (40%) | ||
| 71 | 032302 | Teach Oscail | TC Border Youth Project | €511,978.99 | 39 (65%) | 36 (60%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 39 (65%) | 36 (60%) | ||
| 72 | 032200 | The Peace Factory | Troubles Past – Future Peace Project | £500,000.00 | 36 (60%) | 18 (30%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 36 (60%) | 18 (30%) | ||
| 73 | 029973 | Youth Action Northern Ireland | Reconciling communities: Champions for Change | £499,986.00 | 36 (60%) | 39 (65%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Recommended for Stage 2 Assessment: In addition to team notes the following are to be added: · Clarification of number of beneficiaries and recruitment/selection strategy is required · Confirmation of cross border/cross community participation ratio. · Clarification of whether the target for participation includes new people or people who have already availed of the previous project | 36 (60%) | 39 (65%) | ||
| 74 | 032208 | CrossfireTrust | Restoring Hope Continued | £499,983.08 | 33 (55%) | 36 (60%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 33 (55%) | 36 (60%) | ||
| 75 | 032147 | Carrickfergus YMCA | Corner Stone Project | £499,216.33 | 36 (60%) | 36 (60%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 36 (60%) | 36 (60%) | ||
| 76 | 032104 | Charter for NI | Engaging the past - building a future | £487,073.00 | 33 (55%) | 30 (50%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 33 (55%) | 30 (50%) | ||
| 77 | 032206 | New Life Counselling | New Generation | £481,286.13 | 24 (40%) | 27 (45%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 24 (40%) | 27 (45%) | ||
| 78 | 032265 | The Scout Link Trust | Project Citizen 12 | £472,586.00 | 25.5 (42.5%) | 30 (50%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 25.5 (42.5%) | 30 (50%) | ||
| 79 | 032276 | Ulster Hockey Union | More than a game | £455,920.00 | 24 (40%) | 24 (40%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 24 (40%) | 24 (40%) | ||
| 80 | 032037 | University of Ulster | Accessing Prison Memories | £447,605.00 | 27 (45%) | 33 (55%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 27 (45%) | 33 (55%) | ||
| 81 | 032329 | Omagh Support and Self Help Group | Imparting skills and knowledge to reinforce the | £432,596.50 | 27 (45%) | 27 (45%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 27 (45%) | 27 (45%) | ||
| 82 | 032273 | Ocean Youth Trust Ireland | The X-Adventure Project | £425,900.00 | 24 (40%) | 30 (50%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 24 (40%) | 30 (50%) | ||
| 83 | 032266 | Ballynafeigh Community Development Association (BCDA) | The Social Theatre Laboratory – Creating Change Project | £424,019.00 | 27 (45%) | 33 (55%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 27 (45%) | 33 (55%) | ||
| 84 | 032235 | Falls Community Council | Pieces of the Past | £417,947.15 | 30 (50%) | 33 (55%) | Rejection: Project does not meet the quality threshold for Programme/Priority Theme Objectives | Rejected | 30 (50%) | 33 (55%) | ||
| 85 | 032230 | Border Arts 2000 | The Jigsaw Peace Project | £404,032.00 |
© Copyright Community Relations Council 2013 | |||||||
